"Holiday Tree" Causes Outrage Among Many, Including MHS Students by Paige Kelloway

Co-Editor-in-Chief Paige Kelloway explores the phenomenon behind the "Holiday Tree" proposed by Rhode Island's governor and the ripple effects that it has caused all the way to MHS students.

Rhode Island Governor Lincoln Chafee shocked many, including me, when he announced a couple of weeks ago that the 17-foot spruce standing in the State House is a “holiday tree,” not a “Christmas tree.” Chafee claims that he is honoring Roger Williams by removing the Christmas out of the tree because Williams founded the state in 1636 on the basis of freedom of religion.

For me, this is my favorite time of the year. The music, the presents, the food – and the tree. Attempting to rename the Christmas tree is an unreasonable idea that will most definitely not catch on. I am not going to start calling my tree a “holiday tree,” and I’m sure many other people and businesses that sell these trees would agree.

It has been called a Christmas tree for as long as anyone can remember. I do not consider myself a person rooted in tradition, but why change something that has served as a symbol of a cheerful holiday for so long?

It makes sense to call this time of year the holiday season because it includes holidays from a few different religions and cultures. However, there is no reason to change the name of the tree because it is specific to Christmas. I don’t think people who do not celebrate Christmas get offended when people say “Christmas tree,” just like people who do not celebrate Hanukah would not approve of when people say “menorah.” 

Shannon Abel, a senior at Marblehead High School who celebrates the holiday, agrees. “I think it’s dumb. It’s a Christmas tree. Everyone knows that. There’s no point in changing that now, especial because it’s specifically for Christmas.”

Zach Romanovsky, also a senior but who celebrates Hanukah, agrees as well. “I think it’s stupid. I’m not going to start calling my Hanukah bush a holiday bush.”

Governor Chafee’s office has received over 3,500 phone calls from people who are upset over his announcement and only 92 calls from those who support it (according to his spokeswoman). Dozens of people also attended the annual tree lighting and protested his words by singing the carol “Oh Christmas Tree.” After this, Chafee said, “If it's in my house it's a Christmas tree, but when I'm representing all of Rhode Island I have to be respectful of everyone. Now we can get back to next year's budget...with pleasure.”

Clearly, the governor’s idea will not stick and the “Christmas tree” will always be known as just that. Efforts for inclusion of other religions seem vain, and frankly, other religions aren’t going to identify with the Christmas tree. “Oh Christmas Tree” won’t be having any lyric changes soon.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Missy Scarlet January 10, 2012 at 05:55 PM
Outrage? Really? I can see aggravation, irritation perhaps, but outrage? Politicians will always walk on eggshells during the holidays trying to ruffle as few feathers as possible, and they will make some decisions like calling a Christmas tree a Holiday tree (yet they don't call a Menorah or an Advent candle wreath a Holiday candlestick...). But really: what difference does it make as long as WE THE PEOPLE are allowed to call it whatever we want. I am not Jewish, but if someone were to wish me a Happy Hanukkah, I would say or think: "thank you" for wishing me well and I'd wish them well too. You would think saying Merry Christmas to a non-Christian or Happy Hanukkah to a non-Jew was equivalent to calling them a nasty name. It's GOOD WISHES folks…it's said in the spirit of kindness. I think those that get upset may be missing a touch of the Holiday Spirit-whichever holiday they happen to have been born into… So let the politicians call it a Holiday tree if that is the only way a Christmas Tree can be displayed in a public place. Next year, why don't we just enjoy the lights and the decorations? We all know it is a Christmas tree. What's next to get "outraged" about…shall we call a Jack-O-Lantern a Holiday Pumpkin?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »